It’s been a while since I read a Mercy Thompson book and I
was a little out of touch when I picked up Smoke Bitten, which is already a twelfth
in the series. But that didn’t matter at all. Briggs has a very reader friendly
writing style and I was soon brought up to speed about what had happened and
who was who, and had no trouble following the story.
This book is slightly smaller in scale than some of the
previous ones when it comes to the size and lethalness of the enemy and attack
on Mercy and her werewolf pack. Not that a killer who can turn into a smoke is
easy to face. To add tension, a portal to Underhill opens to Mercy’s backyard,
a rouge pack threatens Mercy’s, and Adam is suffering from a magical problem he’s
not willing to discuss with Mercy, creating tension between them.
The story opens with an emotional punch, followed by a deceptively
slow unfolding of the main plot. Little things happen here and there, and all
of a sudden it’s time for the final confrontation. Everything works out to
satisfaction in the end, and Mercy learns new things about herself and Adam.
All in all, a good addition to the series.
I received a free copy from NetGalley in exchange for an
honest review.
Tower of Mud and Straw is a short fantasy novel (or a long
short story) that tells an interesting and complex story in the limited space it’s
given. I received a free copy from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
Shea Ashcroft is a disgraced politician who is
ordered to the provinces to oversee a construction of a gigantic tower. Feeling
sorry for himself, he decides to make sure it’s built fast so that he can
return to the queen victorious. But this dream soon crumbles. Dangerous alien
technology is being used for building the tower, and he has no choice but to
remove it, halting the project. Humans are furious, but aliens rejoice: they
tell a story of a similar tower that caused a portal to open and destroy their
world. But Shea is a bit wishy-washy person and easy to persuade. A promise of a
high position in court makes him return the alien technology to start the construction
again—only to discover that the aliens were right. There is a portal forming.
Now the choice becomes between destroying the tower and his future, or letting
the portal destroy everything.
Alongside the main story there is another of Shea’s sister
Lena who has died because of the alien technology, which dictates much of Shea’s
decisions. He meets another Lena, an alien woman opposing the tower and they
fall in love—or at least he does. His decision to continue building the tower
seals Lena’s fate, and Shea is left with the realisation that he has failed two
women he has loved. So how to atone?
The ending is fairly self-evident after a certain point;
there’s only one way it can go for the tower. Shea’s fate, however, could’ve
gone either way. The choice suits a short story better than it would’ve suited
a long novel, though I kind of wished there would have been another way out for Shea.
This was an excellent story that could easily have been a longer
novel too; the world is rich and the politics that are only hinted at here are
complex. The writing style was sparse, a little too sparse at times; it
could’ve used some fleshing out in places, especially when it came to
describing sequences of events. But that, too, suited the short form just fine.
All in all, a great one evening’s read.
A Conventicle of Magpies is the first book in the Bloodskill
duology by L.M.R. Clarke. It’s set in an industrial town of Stamchester in a unique
world with factories, early automobiles, and even some telephones, but also
magic called bloodskill that is available for all. The world is referred to as
Victorian in the book description, but it’s not steampunk/gaslight punk—or very
Victorian in general. Edwardian, maybe, if one absolutely has to utilise period
descriptions from our world. I received a free copy from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
Stamchester is a hotspot of political tension. It has
belonged to one set of people conquered by the Avanish, who have then brought in a
different set of people, the Saosuíasei, to live there as cheap labour while
they plunder the original country of the Saosuíasei. For some reason that isn’t
given a very good explanation for, other than prejudice, the Avanish have now
decided to empty Stamchester of the Saosuíasei, with violence if necessary.
Rook is a young Saosuíasei woman living in the slums where
her people have been banished. She belongs to a gang of women led by Mama
Magpie who steal to protect the Saosuíasei women. When the Avanish begin to move
against the Saosuíasei, the women team up with another gang, Jaguars, to try
to save their people.
The book took a while to get going, or decide what the story
it wanted to tell was. Rook has a lot going on in her life. She has lost an
older sister and father, and has to take care of her ten siblings practically
alone. A serial killer haunts the slums, emptying the victims of blood to use
it in blood magic—a storyline that never really moved the plot and seemed
superfluous despite the importance of blood to all magic users. A childhood
friend has chosen to side with the enemy, much to the sorrow of Rook and her
adoptive sister Kestrel, another gang member. It isn’t until the gangs unite
against the Avanish that the story finds a direction that holds until the end.
Rook is an interesting character who always tries to do the
right thing despite the enormous pressure she is constantly under from every
direction. She’s good with bloodskill and stealing, but not overly superior.
She comes across as a bit aloof though, and apart from Kestrel, she doesn’t
really connect with any of the side characters. And neither does the reader.
Side characters were the main weakness of the story. There
were simply too many of them, and the focus never stayed in them long enough
for the reader to form an attachment. At the beginning of the book there were
one set of people with Rook, in the middle there was another, and then again a new
set, none of which were properly introduced to the reader. They simply appear, do
their part in that section of the plot, and then disappear.
The character most ill served by this was Kestrel, Rook’s
stalwart companion and the main side character. She was clearly meant to give
the book LBQT+ status, but she turned out to be a mere token. She’s a biological
male presenting as a woman, but her main concern seemed to be her looks, and
her only role was to save Rook from scrapes. I found it especially
disappointing that she was pushed aside when the plot required infiltration to
a women’s prison. The excuse was that she would have to strip, but that didn’t even
happen to the women who eventually participated, publicly anyway.
It’s an author’s job to put their characters in difficult
situations, and then extradite them whilst staying true to their
characteristics, not push them aside when they become incovenient for the story. There would’ve been plenty of ways to include Kestrel, but she
wasn’t. So, instead of being inclusive, the message here is that she isn’t good
enough as she is to have agency or a proper role, even as a side character in a make-believe
world. I hope this is done better in the next book.
The book ends when the war with the Avanish finally begins.
I find it difficult to imagine how the Saosuíasei will save the day against
the far superior enemy who have almost destroyed them already. But, despite the
issues I had with this book, I’m definitely going to find out how the story
ends.
A Wizard's Guide to Defensive Baking by T. Kingfisher
This is the fourth book by T. Kingfisher that I’ve read—pretty
much back to back—and the first one meant for younger readers. T. Kingfisher is
a penname for Ursula Vernon, who mostly writes children’s books, but according
to her afterword, A Wizard’s Guide to Defensive Baking was deemed too dark for
her audience by all publishers who had shown interest in it, so she published
it under her adult penname.
Mona is a fourteen-year-old baker who works at her aunt’s
bakery, happily making bread and muffins. She’s also a minor wizard with
affinity to baking—and only to that. She can persuade her dough to have the
desired density or the bread not to burn in the oven. And she can animate
gingerbread men to amuse her customers. She’s also responsible for the world’s
angriest sour bread starter, Bob. It eats rats.
Everything is perfect, until the day Mona finds a dead girl
on the floor of the bakery. Someone is killing all minor mages in their town. It’s
followed by a fearmongering campaign against them, and a call for all mages to
register. Angered by this, Mona decides to demand that the leader of her town
do something about it, and gets pulled into dangerous political plotting. Soon
she finds herself as the only mage left in town and it’s up to her to defend it
with magic. And since it’s bread she knows, it’s bread she uses.
I found this an excellent book. Mona was a great character,
resourceful and determined, and she grew a great deal during the course of the
book. The story was intriguing and stakes were high enough to keep an adult’s
interest. Descriptions of Mona’s magic were fun, and the side characters were
great; special mention goes to the gingerbread man who was brilliant. I’m absolutely
sure that I would’ve loved this book when I was twelve too. Yes, there were
dead bodies and evil adults, but so there were in many other books too that I
read at that age. Magic is always intriguing, especially when it’s used as
imaginatively as it is here, and a child rising to save the day when adults can’t
is always appealing. I would definitely recommend this to middle grade readers.
Battle Ground is already seventeenth book in the Dresden
Files UF series about Harry Dresden, the only professional wizard in Chicago. There was a long gap between books fifteen and sixteen, which
ended with an epic two-part story consisting of Peace Talks and this one.
Battle Ground is a good book, but exhausting. Sooo
exhausting. It starts right where the previous book ended, at the same scene,
on the eve of a great battle against an ancient goddess. From there it’s
basically nonstop war, with the enemy getting bigger and more brutal, forcing Harry
to become bigger and more brutal too, which isn’t always good for him. Once
the action starts, there are barely any breathers for the reader to rest for a
minute or two. I had to put the book aside several times just to be able to go
on. There are some sad moments—it is a battle, after all—the biggest taking
place surprisingly early in the book, but the narrative doesn’t really pause
for them either, to let the reader mourn. The war takes precedence.
I’m not entirely sure it was a good idea to split into two
books what could have been one with more brutal editing. Peace Talks especially
was full of filler scenes that could’ve been cut, and the epic battle in Battle
Ground could’ve been shorter. What turned out to be the main story arc between
the two—Thomas’s fate and the new baddie—was completely lost in unnecessary
noise, and only became visible as an afterthought in the last chapter, where we
learned in one sentence why Thomas had attacked the goblin king in the first place. I’d given Peace Talks four stars originally—most likely because I was so happy there was a new Dresden Files book—but after reading both, I don’t think it deserves more than three stars either.
I’m also not happy with how Murphy was treated in these two books. It was as if
the author didn’t know what to do with her now that she and Harry were
romantically involved. Physically broken, she was made a bit too dependent on
him, and that wasn’t good for her, which she rightly railed against—and was
punished for. And I do mean punished, in the meanest and most unnecessary way
possible, robbing her off all glory and agency.
Going in, I was sure this would be the last book in the
series. But once the dust had settled and Harry had had a chance to take a
stock of his life, it turned out there’s more to him yet. The ending put him
firmly in a new place in life—the table was definitely cleared for it—though
not entirely to his liking. I was ready to give up the series that was
once my absolute favourite, but I think I’ll hang on to see how Harry will wriggle
his way out of that.
The edition I read had a short story at the end. It was a sweet
Christmas story, and nicely cleansing after the book itself. Left me feeling
much better.